Cargo Boxes
The Best Roof Cargo Baskets
Open baskets are the underrated middle of this category: cheaper than a box, better at awkward shapes, and worse at absolutely everything else.
Roof & Route is funded by affiliate commission. If you buy through a link on this page we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. It never decides what we recommend or the order we recommend it in — read the full disclosure.
A roof basket is a steel tray with walls. That is the whole product, and its virtues follow directly from the simplicity: it takes shapes a hard box refuses, it has tie-down points all the way round, it costs far less than a box, and you can throw a muddy tent into it without a second thought.
Its vices follow just as directly. No weather protection, no security, and meaningfully more wind noise than a closed box, because air goes through the mesh rather than over it. Most baskets sell a wind fairing separately for exactly this reason, and you should budget for one.
The combination that makes baskets genuinely good value is a basket plus a waterproof bag plus a net. That gets you weather protection and shape flexibility, usually for less than a comparable box.
Quick picks
Tap any row to jump to the full write-up below. Scores are our editorial judgment on published specifications — not a star rating, and not a product we claim to have tested.
| # | Product | Best for | Score | Price |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 |  Thule Canyon XTExpandable, well finished, and with tie-down points where you actually need them rather than where they were easy to weld. | Best overall basket | 7.8 | |
| 2 | Yakima LoadWarriorDesigned to take Yakima's bike and boat mounts on its rails, so the basket is not the end of what the roof can do. | Best for stacking gear on top | 7.7 | |
| 3 | CURT 18115 Roof Rack Cargo CarrierA plain steel tray at a fraction of brand money. It does the one job baskets do, without the finish. | Best budget basket | 7.5 | |
| 4 | Mockins Rooftop Cargo BasketUsually sold with a waterproof bag and a net, which is exactly the combination a basket needs anyway. | Best bundle for a first trip | 7.6 |
Prices checked September 25, 2026. Product photographs are representative stock images, not the exact unit. Affiliate disclosure.
#1 · Best overall basket
Thule Canyon XT
Expandable, well finished, and with tie-down points where you actually need them rather than where they were easy to weld.
- Material
- Steel
- Extension
- Available add-on section
- Mounting
- Bolts to crossbars
- Fairing
- Sold separately
What works
- The extension turns one basket into two sizes
- Sensible tie-down point placement
- Finish holds up to salt better than the budget tier
What doesn’t
- Heavy empty, which eats a modest roof limit
- Fairing is an extra purchase and you will want it
- Costs more than twice some alternatives here
Our scoring
7.8overall
#2 · Best for stacking gear on top
Yakima LoadWarrior
Designed to take Yakima's bike and boat mounts on its rails, so the basket is not the end of what the roof can do.
- Material
- Steel
- Extension
- Stackable extension available
- Mounting
- Bolts to crossbars
- Extra
- Accepts Yakima accessory mounts
What works
- Takes bike and boat mounts on the basket rails
- Stackable extension for tall loads
- Good tie-down geometry for strapping over the top
What doesn’t
- Heavy
- Noisy without a fairing
- Accessory compatibility is strongest within Yakima's own range
Our scoring
7.7overall
#3 · Best budget basket
CURT 18115 Roof Rack Cargo Carrier
A plain steel tray at a fraction of brand money. It does the one job baskets do, without the finish.
- Material
- Steel
- Mounting
- Bolts to crossbars
- Extras
- None
- Finish
- Powder coat
What works
- Considerably cheaper than the name-brand baskets
- No features to fail
- Perfectly adequate tie-down points
What doesn’t
- No fairing option, so noise is what it is
- Powder coat is the weak point in a salted winter
- Assembly hardware is basic
Our scoring
7.5overall
#4 · Best bundle for a first trip
Mockins Rooftop Cargo Basket
Usually sold with a waterproof bag and a net, which is exactly the combination a basket needs anyway.
- Material
- Steel
- Bundle
- Often includes bag, net and straps
- Mounting
- Bolts to crossbars
- Use case
- Occasional trips
What works
- One purchase covers basket, weather protection and restraint
- Cheapest route to a complete working setup
- Fine for a few trips a year
What doesn’t
- Bundled bag and net are built to the bundle price
- Heavier and less refined than the brand baskets
- Bundled straps are the first thing we would upgrade
Our scoring
7.6overall
Baskets are noisy, and the fairing is not optional
A closed box presents a smooth surface to the air. A mesh basket presents a grid, and air moving through a grid at 70 mph makes a sound you will hear for the whole trip.
A wind fairing — a curved deflector across the front of the basket — redirects air over the top instead of through the mesh. It is usually sold separately and it makes a material difference. Budget for one, or accept that this will be the loudest thing on this site.
Our wind noise guide covers the other fixes that work, including bar position and the cheap ones you can do with cord.
The weight problem
Steel baskets are heavy. That is a genuine issue on a vehicle with a modest published roof limit, because the basket is spending your allowance before you load anything.
Work it out before you buy: your published roof limit, minus crossbars, minus the empty basket. On a car rated at 150 lb, a heavy basket and a set of bars can leave you under 100 lb of usable capacity — the same arithmetic as a hard box, for less weather protection.
Which is the honest case against baskets on small cars, and for them on trucks and larger SUVs. Check your own figure on your vehicle page.
Loading a basket safely
An open basket is the easiest place on a car to load badly, because nothing is holding anything in but you.
- Heaviest items low and centered between the crossbars, not over the ends.
- Strap over the load in both directions — front to back and side to side.
- Use cam straps rather than ratchets over soft or fragile items.
- Net over the top as a backup, never as the primary restraint.
- Walk round and tug everything before you leave, and again at the first stop.
Full technique, including which hardware and which knots, is in how to tie down cargo.
Common questions
Is a roof basket better than a cargo box?
Do I need a wind fairing for a roof basket?
How much does a roof basket weigh?
Sources
Not sure it fits your car?
Our vehicle pages carry the published roof load limit, the roof type by model year, and what actually mounts to it — cited, and honest about what the manufacturer does not publish.
Read next
The Best Rooftop Cargo Bags
Soft roof bags with and without a rack, what they cost you, and the vehicles that should not use one.
The Best Cargo Nets
Nets for roof and hitch baskets — what they stop, and why they are never the primary restraint.
How to Tie Down Cargo
Anchor points, strap direction, correct tension, tail management and the pre-drive checks.
Are Roof Racks Noisy? And How to Stop It
What makes a roof rack whistle, and the fixes that actually work, in order of effectiveness.